Insights / Software spend

Should you rebuild that software tool inside your ERP?

6 minute read · Dellajax

Most finance teams pay for a handful of tools that each do one job: invoice audit, approvals, commission statements, credit checks, document capture. Some are worth every dollar. Others duplicate what your ERP could already do if someone built it.

Score each tool

Rate each tool from 1 to 5 on these questions. A high total means it is a good candidate to rebuild.

QuestionRebuild signal
How much of the tool do you actually use?You use one or two features of a large product
Where does the data live?Mostly in your ERP already; the tool copies it out and back
How often does the logic change?Rarely, and the rules are yours, not the vendor's
How many people use it?A small internal team
Does it depend on a network or outside data?No; it doesn't rely on data only the vendor has

When to keep paying

  • The tool depends on data or a network you can't reproduce, like credit bureaus, tax rate engines or payment networks.
  • It is heavily regulated, like payroll tax filing.
  • The vendor ships meaningful improvements every quarter that you would never build yourself.

Count the real cost of building

A rebuild is not free. Budget for the build itself, testing, documentation, a named owner and ongoing maintenance when the ERP updates. If nobody will own it, keep the subscription.

Run a side-by-side before you cancel

  1. Build the replacement for the highest-value 80% of what the tool does.
  2. Run both for a full cycle, usually one or two months, on the same transactions.
  3. Compare results line by line and log every difference.
  4. Fix gaps, then cancel only when the new process matches or beats the old one.
Tip: check your renewal dates first. The best time to start a side-by-side is three to four months before a renewal.

Want this done for you?

We build these processes inside your ERP, usually NetSuite. Start with a free 30-minute teardown.